When Being Called "Smart" Backfires: The Hidden Struggles of "Gifted" Children

Meet seven-year-old Marcus. Mathematics comes easily to him, so easily that he solves problems his older fifth-grade sister finds challenging.
Adults shower him with praise: "You're so brilliant!" "What a gifted child!" Marcus thrives on these compliments.

Then comes the day when a problem doesn't yield to his first attempt. The answer doesn't materialize instantly. Suddenly, fear takes hold.

"I must not be as clever as they think," he murmurs, fighting back tears. "I can't solve this."

This seemingly minor setback reveals a troubling pattern observed in educational settings worldwide: children lauded for their innate abilities often become the most vulnerable learners. They shy away from difficulty. They abandon tasks when immediate success eludes them. And surprisingly, despite their early advantages, they frequently face greater challenges as they progress.

‍

How Compliments Can Become Constraints

Dr. Carol Dweck from Stanford University conducted a revealing study. Children were given puzzles, then received one of two types of feedback:

Group A was told: "You're incredibly smart!"
Group B heard: "You put in excellent effort!"

The outcomes were striking:

• 90% of children praised for intelligence selected simpler puzzles in subsequent rounds to guarantee success
• 90% of children praised for effort chose more challenging puzzles to enhance their learning

A single word, "smart", created an invisible barrier. These children prioritized protecting their label over expanding their capabilities.

‍

When Intelligence Feels Like a Fixed Asset

Children celebrated for being "naturally talented" typically develop what psychologists call a fixed mindset—the conviction that intelligence is an innate, unchangeable trait.

Consider eight-year-old Sarah, consistently praised since early childhood as a "born artist." When she receives her first critical feedback on her artwork, she doesn't process it as constructive guidance. Instead, she hears it as evidence that perhaps she lacks true talent after all.

Art transforms from joy to threat. Feedback feels like exposure. She retreats into safe, familiar territory.

This pattern emerges across all domains. Children labeled "natural-born leaders," "mathematical prodigies," or "athletic phenoms" frequently stop exploring new territory—not from lack of interest, but from terror of being revealed as ordinary.

‍

What Neuroscience Reveals

Brain research confirms these behavioral observations. Research by Dr. Jason Moser demonstrates that individuals with growth mindsets—those who believe abilities develop through practice—show heightened neural activity when encountering errors.
Their brains engage more intensely with challenges. In contrast, children with fixed mindsets show diminished brain activity when they make mistakes. They mentally disengage. Learning pathways close down.For developing minds, this response pattern is particularly harmful. Believing abilities are fixed actually prevents the formation of neural connections necessary for mastery.

‍

The Perfectionist Paradox

Dr. Brené Brown describes perfectionism as a "20-ton shield" children wield against vulnerability. Those labeled gifted often adopt this shield remarkably early. Perfectionism doesn't produce excellence, it generates paralysis.
Take ten-year-old David, praised as an exceptional reader. He spends three hours on a book report that should require thirty minutes. He's not being thorough—he's terrified of imperfection.

Studies show perfectionist children are significantly more likely to:

• Delay starting tasks
• Avoid uncertainty
• Struggle with anxiety and depression

All in service of maintaining an impossible standard.

The Comparison Trap

The "gifted" label also breeds constant comparison with peers.
Dr. Leon Festinger's research established that humans naturally compare themselves to others. For children labeled gifted, these comparisons become threats to their identity.
Emma earned the "gifted" label in kindergarten. By third grade, she expects academic dominance. When classmates excel in areas where she's average, her self-worth crumbles.
Rather than viewing others' strengths as inspiration, she perceives them as competition—and withdraws.

‍

Why "Gifted" Children Fear Hard Work

Many talented children develop an aversion to effort itself. The reason? They've internalized the belief that genuine intelligence makes everything effortless.
So when something finally requires sustained work, panic sets in. They assume they've reached their limit. Instead of persevering through the challenge, they disengage.
This creates a destructive cycle: Avoid difficult tasks → Skills stagnate → Fear challenges more → Avoid even more.
Psychologists call this effort aversion, and it can undermine grit, resilience, and long-term success.

‍

The Origins of Impostor Syndrome

Fast-forward to adulthood. Many formerly "gifted" children now feel like frauds. They've spent years performing rather than genuinely learning.
Dr. Pauline Clance's research shows that early praise for innate ability frequently leads to impostor syndrome - the persistent fear that success is undeserved.
They think: "If I were truly intelligent, this wouldn't be so hard." They've never learned to trust the process; only the performance.

‍

Understanding What Talent Actually Means

Society romanticizes "natural talent," but reality tells a different story—one that's both more grounded and more encouraging.
Dr. K. Anders Ericsson's research demonstrates that excellence in any field emerges from deliberate practice—approximately 10,000 hours of it.
Early exposure, quality instruction, supportive environments; these factors contribute to children's initial success. But none guarantee sustained achievement.
Early promise isn't destiny, it's merely a head start.

‍

The Growth-Focused Alternative

How should we speak to our children?
Replace praise for fixed traits with recognition of effort, strategy, and progress.

Instead of: "You're so intelligent!"
Try: "You developed a clever approach to that problem!"

Instead of: "You're a born athlete!"
Try: "Your consistent practice is really paying off!"

Instead of: "You're musically gifted!"
Try: "Your dedication is making your performances truly beautiful!"

‍

Celebrate Process Over Person

Focus your recognition on:

• Strategy: "You explored multiple approaches—that's smart thinking!"
• Effort: "You persisted even when it became challenging."
• Progress: "Notice how much you've improved since last month!"
• Learning: "That mistake helped you discover something important!"

These shifts cultivate resilient, confident, self-directed learners.

‍

‍

Reframing Difficulty

When children understand that struggle drives growth, everything shifts.
Nine-year-old Alex encounters a challenging math problem. Rather than saying, "I'm not good at this," he thinks: "My brain is about to get stronger!"
This mindset transforms mistakes from roadblocks into stepping stones.

‍

The Long-Term Benefits

Children praised for effort rather than ability:

• Recover more quickly from setbacks
• Achieve more in challenging environments
• Manage emotions more effectively
• Take creative and leadership risks
• Report higher life satisfaction

They aren't performers—they're learners. And they continue developing.

The Parental Transformation

This doesn't mean never celebrating your child's strengths. But shift from praising what they are to celebrating who they're becoming.

Rather than raising "the intelligent one," raise the curious one. Rather than raising "the talented one," raise the determined one.

‍

Embracing Productive Struggle

Struggle is the pathway to success. The brain builds new neural connections when challenged. That's where genuine growth occurs.
When children understand this, they stop fearing effort, and they start welcoming it. 

‍

The Real Gift

The greatest gift isn't being called "talented." It's understanding your abilities can grow. When we praise effort, learning, and persistence, we help children unlock their authentic potential.

Allow them to fail. Allow them to struggle. Allow them to rise. That's where the real transformation happens.

Next time you're tempted to say "You're naturally good at that," pause. Ask yourself: "How can I acknowledge effort while keeping the door open for growth?" That shift in language could change a life.

The most successful people aren't those who never struggled. They're the ones who learned to view struggle as the price of growth. Give your children that understanding.

Every child possesses the potential to grow, learn, and flourish, not because of a "gifted" label, but because effort, curiosity, and resilience form the true foundations of lasting achievement. This article explores how shifting our praise from talent to growth helps all children embrace challenges and unlock their genuine potential.

‍